Luxury Hotels in Tuscany
17 luxury hotels compared on guest reviews. No paid placements.
Tripplo’s selection · Founder: Axel Hernborg · Updated 27 October 2026
Our picks
Best overall
Families
Views
Boutique4.Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel, Tuscany€€€€Booking9.6· 82 reviews
Spa & wellness
17 Recommended Hotels
Castelfalfi
Tuscany, Italy
Best overallThe property, set among the rolling Tuscan hills, consists of a main building and a beautifully restored former tobacco warehouse, with a total of 146 rooms and suites. Each room is elegantly…
Why this position
Leads the ranking on the weight of evidence: 249 reviews to #2's 146, although #2 scores higher (9.7 to 9.6).
Borgo Pignano Volterra Tuscany
Tuscany, Italy
FamiliesIn the Tuscan countryside, surrounded by the hills of Volterra and 750 hectares of private gardens and woods, Borgo Pignano Volterra Tuscany has an outdoor pool, a children’s club and a restaurant…
Why this position
Among the three highest guest scores of the 17 hotels we rank here: 9.7 from 146 reviews. Scores higher than #1 (9.7 to 9.6), on a smaller body of reviews (146 to 249).
Lupaia
Tuscany, Italy
ViewsOn a Tuscan hilltop, Lupaia, a converted stone farmhouse overlooking Montepulciano, will offer you a warm welcome…
Why this position
The same guest score as #2 (9.7), on a smaller body of reviews (96 to 146).
Watch the walkthrough of Tuscany
Luxury hotels in Tuscany – 4 details you did not know
Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel, Tuscany
Tuscany, Italy
BoutiqueSurrounded by the Tuscan countryside, Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel, Tuscany features an outdoor pool, spa and fitness centre and 2 restaurants. This former castle provides elegant rooms and…
Why this position
Sits behind #3 on both the score (9.6 to 9.7) and the sample it rests on (82 to 96 reviews).
Castello Banfi - Il Borgo - Relais et Chateaux
Tuscany, Italy
Set on a hilltop 10 km from Montalcino overlooking its own vineyards, Castello Banfi - Il Borgo - Relais et Chateaux offers an outdoor pool, gym and its own winery and cellar. The restaurant serves…
Why this position
Rests on more guest reviews than #4 (133 to 82), at a slightly lower score (9.4 to 9.6).
Castiglion del Bosco, A Rosewood Hotel
Tuscany, Italy
Spa & wellnessCastiglion del Bosco, A Rosewood Hotel is a luxury hotel in the Tuscan countryside located 12 km from Montalcino. It features comfortable rooms, an outdoor swimming pool with panoramic views, and free…
Why this position
Scores higher than #5 (9.7 to 9.4), on a smaller body of reviews (43 to 133).
Borgo Dei Conti Resort Relais & Chateaux
Tuscany, Italy
Offering a free spa and a gym, Borgo Dei Conti Resort Relais & Chateaux is set in a 20-hectare estate overlooking the Nestore Valley. A fortified 17th-century mansion, it has an Umbrian restaurant…
Why this position
Rests on more guest reviews than #6 (56 to 43), at a slightly lower score (9.4 to 9.7).
Borgo San Felice Resort
Tuscany, Italy
Borgo San Felice Resort is located in Castelnuovo Berardenga, in the Chianti wine district. It offers spacious rooms with antique furnishings, a swimming pool, and panoramic views…
Why this position
Level with #7 on the guest score (9.4) and on the reviews behind it.
ADLER Thermae
Tuscany, Italy
All inclusiveSet in the beautiful Val D'Orcia valley, ADLER Thermae offers over 1000 m² of indoor and outdoor swimming pools with regenerating and therapeutic thermal water, with panoramic views of the Tuscan…
Why this position
Rests on more guest reviews than #8 (123 to 47), at a slightly lower score (9.2 to 9.4).
COMO Castello Del Nero
Tuscany, Italy
DiningCOMO Castello Del Nero is set in the Chianti wine area, between Florence and Siena, and dates back to the 12th century. It features a COMO Shambhala retreat with outdoor pool and offers free parking…
Why this position
The same guest score as #9 (9.2), on a smaller body of reviews (96 to 123).
Borgo Santo Pietro
Tuscany, Italy
Just outside Chiusdino in the Tuscan countryside, Borgo Santo Pietro has 5 hectares of private gardens. Dating back to the 1200s, it features a swimming pool with bar and terrace…
Why this position
The same guest score as #10 (9.2), on a smaller body of reviews (23 to 96).
Il Pellicano
Tuscany, Italy
BeachIl Pellicano is composed of a main building and a cluster of cottages scattered around the hotel's gardens. The heated swimming pool is filled with seawater, and there is also a tennis court with…
Why this position
Rests on more guest reviews than #11 (33 to 23), at a slightly lower score (9.0 to 9.2).
Castello di Velona Resort, Thermal SPA & Winery
Tuscany, Italy
Set on a hill overlooking Val d’Orcia, Castello di Velona Resort, Thermal SPA & Winery features a restaurant and a spa centre for an additional charge. The property is also reachable via helicopter…
Why this position
Rests on more guest reviews than #12 (213 to 33), at a slightly lower score (8.9 to 9.0).
Fonteverde Thermal Spa Resort Tuscany - The Leading Hotels of the World
Tuscany, Italy
The elegant Fonteverde Thermal Spa Resort Tuscany - The Leading Hotels of the World hotel in the Val d'Orcia features a fully equipped SPA & Thermal center, spectacular panoramic pools, naturally…
Why this position
Guests rate it above #13 (8.9 to 8.9) and on more reviews (953 to 213).
Via Roma 33 Tuscany Boutique Hotel & Spa - Adults Only
Tuscany, Italy
Affordable luxuryVia Roma 33 Tuscany Boutique Hotel & Spa - Adults Only is a modern, upper four-star house for couples who want to slow down in a quiet corner of Tuscany… It is an adults-only hotel for guests aged 16 and over, set in Stia in the Casentino Valley, and its wellness centre, with a warm indoor pool, an outdoor pool, a sauna, a Turkish bath and a hot tub, stays open into the evening. Guests praise the staff above all, along with spacious, spotless rooms and a breakfast built on local produce. The setting is also the main trade-off. Stia is small and rural, and Florence Airport is 59 km away, so a car is close to essential. Some rooms put the shower behind a glass panel facing the bed, and a few extras, such as massages and some breakfast items, cost more than guests expected. Couples who want a calm spa base with good food will feel at home; families with children under 16 cannot stay.
Why this position
Scores higher than #14 (9.4 to 8.9), on a smaller body of reviews (783 to 953).
La Bandita Townhouse
Tuscany, Italy
DesignLa Bandita Townhouse is set in Pienza and features free bikes, garden and terrace. Among the facilities at this property are a shared lounge and a concierge service, along with free WiFi throughout…
Why this position
Sits behind #15 on both the score (9.1 to 9.4) and the sample it rests on (56 to 783 reviews).
Castello di Spaltenna Exclusive Resort & Spa
Tuscany, Italy
Set in Tuscany's countryside, Castello di Spaltenna Exclusive Resort & Spa is an ancient monastery from the 10th century. It offers 2 swimming pools, one of which is heated, a restaurant and spacious…
Why this position
Guests rate it above #16 (9.1 to 9.1) and on more reviews (178 to 56).
Loading map...
Luxury travel, straight to your inbox
Every other week we share destinations and hotels worth the journey, from hidden boutique hideaways to classics that live up to their name.
When is it cheapest?
Nightly prices over the coming months compared with each hotel's own usual price, from Tripplo's daily price checks.
October
7% dearer
November
1% cheaper
Updated daily. We only show months with price checks from at least eight hotels.
Ranking updated 16 October 2026
17 hotels compared · How we choose hotels · No paid placements
Compare the hotels
| # | Hotel | Stars | Guest rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Castelfalfi | 5★ | Booking9.6· 249 reviews | Best overall |
| 2 | Borgo Pignano Volterra Tuscany | 5★ | Booking9.7· 146 reviews | Families |
| 3 | Lupaia | 5★ | Booking9.7· 96 reviews | Views |
| 4 | Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel, Tuscany | 5★ | Booking9.6· 82 reviews | Boutique |
| 5 | Castello Banfi - Il Borgo - Relais et Chateaux | 5★ | Booking9.4· 133 reviews | — |
| 6 | Castiglion del Bosco, A Rosewood Hotel | 5★ | Booking9.7· 43 reviews | Spa & wellness |
| 7 | Borgo Dei Conti Resort Relais & Chateaux | 5★ | Booking9.4· 56 reviews | — |
| 8 | Borgo San Felice Resort | 5★ | Booking9.4· 47 reviews | — |
| 9 | ADLER Thermae | 5★ | Booking9.2· 123 reviews | All inclusive |
| 10 | COMO Castello Del Nero | 5★ | Booking9.2· 96 reviews | Dining |
| 11 | Borgo Santo Pietro | 5★ | Booking9.2· 23 reviews | — |
| 12 | Il Pellicano | 5★ | Booking9· 33 reviews | Beach |
| 13 | Castello di Velona Resort, Thermal SPA & Winery | 5★ | Booking8.9· 213 reviews | — |
| 14 | Fonteverde Thermal Spa Resort Tuscany - The Leading Hotels of the World | 5★ | Booking8.9· 953 reviews | — |
| 15 | Via Roma 33 Tuscany Boutique Hotel & Spa - Adults Only | 4★ | Booking9.4· 783 reviews | Affordable luxury |
| 16 | La Bandita Townhouse | 4★ | Booking9.1· 56 reviews | Design |
| 17 | Castello di Spaltenna Exclusive Resort & Spa | 4★ | Booking9.1· 178 reviews | — |
Download the comparison as a PDF
All 17 hotels in one PDF to save, print or share with whoever you are travelling with.
- Who each hotel suits
- What guests like – and what they complain about
- A link to every hotel for when it is time to book
Free · instant download
How we ranked these hotels
17 hotels looked at for this destination: 17 ranked above, 0 more we recommend.
The Google and Booking ratings for these hotels are based on a combined 3,310 reviews reported by the sources. This is not the number of review texts Tripplo has analysed.
How guest ratings, hotel class and facts inform our selections.
Read our methodologyTuscany: weather and sea temperature
Right now: 13°
Tripplo price index: Tuscany
€809about £680
Typical price per night at the luxury hotels we recommend
8 hotels · check-in 29 Oct–27 Nov · two adults, two nights · checked daily by Tripplo
Friday and Saturday check-ins cost about the same per night as the rest of the week.
| Hotel | Usual range | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| La Bandita Townhouse | Typically €389, usually between €389 and €474 | €389 |
| Fonteverde Thermal Spa Resort Tuscany - The Leading Hotels of the World | Typically €415, usually between €346 and €576 | €415 |
| Castello di Velona Resort, Thermal SPA & Winery | Typically €656, usually between €561 and €1,042 | €656 |
| COMO Castello Del Nero | Typically €758, usually between €735 and €849 | €758 |
| Castelfalfi | Typically €860, usually between €791 and €1,010 | €860 |
| Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel, Tuscany | Typically €1,000, usually between €862 and €1,452 | €1,000 |
| Lupaia | Typically €1,148, usually between €906 and €1,544 | €1,148 |
| Castiglion del Bosco, A Rosewood Hotel | Typically €2,539, usually between €1,428 and €2,840 | €2,539 |
Each bar shows how a hotel's nightly price moved over the period, leaving out the most unusual days. The marker is its typical price.
Every hotel counts once, at its own typical price, so hotels we happened to check more often don't carry more weight. Prices are the lowest rate available for the whole stay, worked out per night in euros.
Tripplo's luxury hotel selection in Tuscany in numbers
Most common facilities
- Restaurant (17 of 17)
- Pool (15 of 17)
- Spa & wellness (15 of 17)
- Free WiFi (14 of 17)
- Bar (14 of 17)
- Parking (13 of 17)
What these hotels do best
- Dining (12 of 17)
- Spa & wellness (11 of 17)
- Views (10 of 17)
- Pools (7 of 17)
